Dorothy Gage and Dorothy Gale
by Sally Roesch Wagner
Posted from the Baum Bugle 28.2 (Autumn 1984): 4-6, by courtesy of Fred M. Meyer, former Secretary of the International Wizard of Oz Club, Inc., and of the author, Sally Roesch Wagner, a leading scholar on Matilda Joslyn Gage, L. Frank Baumâ€™s mother-in-law. For a biographical sketch of the author, see the end of the article.
L. Frank Baum loved his wife, Maud Gage Baum. It was as simple as that. The family delighted in recounting the story of their first meeting. Maudâ€™s roommate at Cornell, Josie Baum, was anxious that Maud meet her handsome cousin Frank. Maud was finally introduced to him by Josieâ€™s mother, Josephine, at a Christmas party given by Frankâ€™s sister, Harriet A. B. Neal, in 1881. As Frank and Maudâ€™s son later reported:
The following evening Frank found quite a few of his old friends gathered at Harrietâ€™s house. He crossed the room to greet his sister, sitting in a large armchair. Around her were gathered a group of young people in animated conversation. As he came up and greeted them, Aunt Josie took the arm of a young lady standing near by. Drawing her close, she said: â€œThis is my nephew, Frank. Frank, I want you to know Maud Gage. Iâ€™m sure you will love her.â€ He smiled down at the animated features of a girl with long dark brown hair, mischievous eyes, and slightly retrousse nose. â€œConsider yourself loved, Miss Gage,â€ he said smiling. [Frank Joslyn Baum and Russell P. MacFall, To Please A Child (Chicago: Reilly & Lee, 1961), 43]
The courtship progressed rapidly and, in spite of objections from both families, the two were married the following November in a small, simple ceremony, held in Maudâ€™s motherâ€™s parlor.
Frank was a devoted family man. He was always â€œdecidedly a homebody,â€ his oldest son said, â€œand seldom went out alonealmost never at nightâ€ (letter from Frank Joslyn Baum to Russell P. MacFall, December 31, 1956). Frank was respectful of Maud, and took seriously his responsibilities as a husband. Writing about â€œA Happy Home,â€ in his newspaper the Aberdeen Saturday Pioneer (February 15, 1890), Frank shared with his readers his own contribution to the household:
Few men realize sufficiently that it lies entirely in their hands to make their home life enjoyable or otherwise. In nine cases out of ten a happy home depends on the temperament of the â€œman of the house.â€ A woman is usually so occupied with her household duties and the care of her children that she naturally becomes more or less nervous and irritable, and looks forward to the homecoming of her mate as the one excitement that shall relieve the monotony of her daily routine.
That sensitivity of the plight of the household certainly endeared Frank to Maud. It was difficult raising four active and mischievous boys by herself. And yet, when they jointly decided that Frank must take a job as a traveling salesman for a time, it was Frank, not Maud, who suffered more from the absence. He eagerly awaited her letters from home. Once when he did not receive one for a day or two, he telegraphed that he was coming right home. â€œSeems he wouldnâ€™t travel if he didnâ€™t hear,â€ his mother-in-law commented, â€œa perfect babyâ€ (letter from Matilda Joslyn Gage to Helen Leslie Gage, February 18, 1897, Matilda Jewell Gage Collection). But Frank was not ashamed of his strong need for Maud. He depended on her support, her advice, and her constancy, as demonstrated in a letter written in 1914, after thirty-two years of marriage:
My darling old Sweetheart, I got your sweet letter today . . . and it was just the letter I would have expected you to write. Aside from the fact that I reproached myself for making my dear wife share my bothers, I got such a heart-warming through that letter that the sweet cheering words will keep me happy for many days to come. Yes, sweetheart, nothing can dismay us while we have each other and while the old love, which has lasted and grown stronger during all these years, remains to comfort and encourage us. . . . Always your lover, Frank. [letter from L. Frank Baum to Maud Gage Baum, October 12, 1914, Laura Jane Musser Collection]
In his â€œHappy Homeâ€ article, he encouraged every husband to discuss business matters with his wife, promising â€œten chances to one, she will give you more wholesome advice than any of your business friends.â€ Business decisions were made jointly in the Baum household, and Frankâ€™s publishers, Reilly & Britton, came to expect letters from Frank to begin, â€œAfter a conference with Mrs. Baum . . . I have decided to . . . .â€ Maud was one of Frankâ€™s best critics, Reilly believed (letter from L. Frank Baum to Frank K. Reilly, November 27, 1915; letter from F. K. Reilly to L. F. Baum, March 20, 1915). Frank was sure of it. When his first childrenâ€™s book, Mother Goose in Prose, was published in 1897, Frank inscribed Maudâ€™s copy:
One critic I always fear and long to please. It is my Sweetheart. Shall I win her approval how vain would be the plaudits of the small remnant of humanity! I hope this book will succeed, for her sake, for we need the money success would bring. But aside from that sordid fact I care little what the world thinks of it. The vital question is: What does my sweetheart, my wife of fifteen years, think of it? [Robert A. Baum Jr. Collection]
Not all men take women this seriously, Frank realized, and in another editorial in the Saturday Pioneer (February 1, 1890), he encouraged all of them to do so, not only privately but publicly as well. â€œWe have one more lesson in tolerance to learn,â€ he wrote. â€œWe must do away with sex prejudice and render equal distinction and reward to brains and ability, no matter whether found in man or woman.â€
Frank was adoring of his wife. He covered a wall of Ozcot, their home in Hollywood, with his favorite pictures of Maud taken throughout her life, and christened them his â€œyard of Maud.â€ On the back of a picture of himself he had taken for her, he wrote, â€œTo my own Sweet Love. The image of your baby. Tooken December 1899.â€ And on the occasion of their twenty-fifth wedding anniversary in 1907, Frank sent out (without his wifeâ€™s knowledge) an invitation with a remarkable, tongue-in-cheek record of their married life:
Quarrels: Just a few.
Wife in tears: Three times (cat died; bonnet spoiled; sore toe).
Husband swore: One thousand one hundred and eighty-seven times; at wife, 0.
Causes of jealousy: 0. (Remarkable in an age of manicured men and beauty doctor women.)
Broke, occasionally; bent, often.<.p>
Now Maud was a bit more restrained in her sentiments, yet similarly devoted. She reassured Frank after one of his frequent financial failures, â€œWe will come [out] all right. Trouble comes to us all but when met bravely and together surely we can stand it. You have always been able to earn a living. For all time and through all things, Your sweetheart and wifeâ€ (Fragment of undated letter, Robert A. Baum Jr. Collection).
Frankâ€™s health, which had never been strong, took a serious turn for the worse in 1918 and, after a prolonged illness, he died on May 6, 1919. Maud was with him constantly to the end. She wrote one of her sisters about their final conversation:
He told me many times I was the only one he had ever loved. He hated to die, did not want to leave me, said he was never happy without me, but it was better he should go first, if it had to be, for I doubt if he could have got along without me. It is all so sad, and I am so forlorn and alone. For nearly thirty-seven years we had been everything to each other, we were happy, and now I am alone, to face the world alone. [letter from Maud Gage Baum to Helen Leslie and Leslie Gage, May 16, 1919, Matilda Jewell Gage Collection]
Yes, it had been a deep and nourishing love for both, marred by only one major disappointment: the lack of a daughter. Frank, who had an affinity with all children, was a doting father to his sons. Yet he desired also a girl. However, it was Maud who, often feeling outnumbered by five males in the household and wishing to carry on the closeness she shared with her mother, sisters, and nieces, longed for a daughter even more than Frank did. Only her mother Matilda Joslyn Gage, the nationally known suffragist, provided Maud with regular female companionship.
Maud was Matildaâ€™s youngest, spunkiest, and favorite child. Mother and daughter were inseparable. They spent months in each otherâ€™s homes when the Baums lived in Syracuse, only a dozen miles from Matildaâ€™s house in Fayetteville; and, when they moved to Aberdeen, South Dakota, in 1888, and then on to Chicago three years later, Matilda passed each winter with Frank, Maud, and the boys. Her company was especially important for Maud when Frank was on the road selling china for Pitkin & Brooks. Matildaâ€™s death in March 1898 left Maud lonely. For the first time in her life, she was without any immediate family close by and without the female companionship of a loved one. â€œIt is just two months ago tonight that Mother left us,â€ Maud lamented to her elder sister. â€œWe have had a terrible electrical storm tonight, and I am very lonely. If I could only see Mother once, if she were only up in her room. Oh, Mother, I am so lonely without you. It does not seem as if I could have it so. She was so thoughtful of me, so worried when I fell ill. I feel as if I had lost all that especially care about me. Frank is good and kind, but he is different from Mother, and I want her so muchâ€ (letter from Maud Gage Baum to Helen Leslie Gage, May 18,1898, Matilda Jewell Gage Collection).
Perhaps there was one link, one connection, one hope. Matilda had been a serious student of the occult during the last decade of her life, and had come to believe (as did Maud) in reincarnation. Matilda explained to one of her grandchildren the year before her own death:
There is one thing I want you to remember first of all: This is that what is called â€œdeathâ€ by people is not death. You are more alive than ever you were after what is called death. Death is only a journey, like going to another country. You are alive when you travel to Aberdeen just as much as when you stay in Edgeley [North Dakota], and it is the same with what is called death. After people have been gone for awhile, they come back and live in another body, in another family and have another name. [letter from Matilda Joslyn Gage to Harry Carpenter, January 21, 1897, Jocelyn Birch Burdick Collection]
And perhaps sometimes they come back to the same family. When Matilda died, her daughter-in-law, Sophie Jewell Gage, was expecting a child. It would be the last of the Gage line, born to Matildaâ€™s only son T. Clarkson Gage. More importantly, this child might be the spiritual connection with the late Matilda Joslyn Gage.
The baby was born in June and she was given a popular name of the time, one that even her Uncle Frank Baum had previously used in Mother Goose in Prose. Sophie had already lost one baby seven years before. Everyone was worried. The child held on for five months but, in November 1898, she died. Maud attended the funeral and was so distraught she had to have medical treatment. â€œDorothy was a perfectly beautiful baby,â€ Maud wrote her sister Helen (letter from Maud Gage Baum to Helen Leslie Gage, November 27, 1898, Matilda Jewell Gage Collection). â€œI could have taken her for my very own and loved her devotedly.â€ Frank was then working on a childrenâ€™s story; and, when it came out in 1900, he dedicated it to â€œmy good friend and comrade, My Wife.â€ And in The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, Frank gave Maud her Dorothy.
This article was suggested to me during a 1975 taping session by Matilda Jewell Gage, L. Frank and Maud Baumâ€™s niece. Matilda was twelve when her sister Dorothy died. When I mentioned the story several years later, Matilda was more inclined to believe that her uncle had come upon the name Dorothy simply because it was a popular girlâ€™s name of the time. As Michael Patrick Hearn has pointed out, however, there is a clear pattern in Baumâ€™s work of using his wifeâ€™s familyâ€™s names. Dorothyâ€™s aunt and uncle may have been named for Maudâ€™s parents: Matilda, who occasionally signed her work â€œMâ€ (Em), and Henry. Matilda Joslyn Gageâ€™s maiden name appears as the family name of The Master Key (1901); likewise â€œJoslynâ€ is the name of the little boy in â€œThe Yellow Rylâ€ (1906), a short story published in A Childâ€™s Garden (August and September 1925), and appears again as a family name in Mary Louise in the Country (1916), here spelled â€œJocelyn.â€ Also, according to his 1905 contract with Reilly & Britton, Baum intended to publish a novel for young people ascribed either to â€œMaud Gage Baumâ€ or to â€œHelen Leslie,â€ the name of Maudâ€™s elder sister. -S.R.W.
Sally Roesch Wagner, a Biographical Sketch
One of the first women to receive a doctorate in this country for work in women's studies (UC Santa Cruz), Sally Roesch Wagner was a founder of one of the earliest college women's studies programs (CSU Sacramento). Having taught women's studies for twenty years, she now tours the country as a writer, lecturer, and historical performer, bringing to life Matilda Joslyn Gage and her better-known woman's rights ally, Elizabeth Cady Stanton. A scholar in residence for the Women's Rights National Historical Park in Seneca Falls, New York, during Celebrate 98, Wagner was curator of two exhibits, developed a curriculum, and performed as both Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Matilda Joslyn Gage. Dr. Wagner is the Director of the Matilda Joslyn Gage Foundation in Fayetteville, New York.
Most recently Wagner appeared as a "talking head" in the Ken Burns PBS documentary, "Not for Ourselves Alone: The Story of Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony," for which she wrote the accompanying faculty guide for PBS. She was also an historian in the PBS special "One Woman, One Vote" and has been interviewed several times on National Public Radio's "All Things Considered" and "Democracy Now." The Jeanette K. Watson Women's Studies Distinguished Visiting Professor in the Humanities at Syracuse University in Spring 1997 and currently adjunct faculty member in the women's studies program there, Wagner has been a consultant to the Publisher, the Writings of Mary Baker Eddy, and the National Women's History Project; she is a Research Affiliate of the Women's Resources and Research Center at the University of California, Davis.
The theme of Wagnerâ€™s work has been telling the untold stories. The exhibit and her monograph of the same name, "She Who Holds the Sky: Matilda Joslyn Gage," reveal a suffragist who was written out of history because of her stand against the Religious Right of a hundred years ago, while her traveling exhibit and Women's Rights National Historical Park curriculum, "Sisters in Spirit," documents the influence of Iroquois women on early women's rights activists. Wagner keynoted the opening session of the 1998 National Women's Studies Association convention with a lecture on this topic. She also briefed the First Lady, the White House Millennium Council, and the press during Hillary Rodham Clinton's historic sites tour.
Her recent essays have appeared in The Encyclopedia of Women and World Religion; Women Public Speakers in the United States, 1800-1925; Indian Roots of American Democracy; Iroquois Women: An Anthology; and Handbook of American Women's History. She has published articles in the National Women's Studies Association Journal, On the Issues, Northeast Indian Quarterly, Indian Country Today, Hartford Courant, Women's History Network News, National NOW Times, and Sacramento Bee.
Her recent books include She Who Holds the Sky: Matilda Joslyn Gage; a Modern Reader's Edition of Matilda Joslyn Gage's 1893 classic, Woman, Church and State; Daughters of Dakota (six-volume series); The Untold Story of the Iroquois Influence on Early Feminists; A Time of Protest: Suffragists Challenge the Republic, 1870-1887, and Celebrating Your Cultural Heritage by Telling the Untold Stories.
Sally Roesch Wagner is director of the Matilda Joslyn Gage Foundation
P. O. Box 192
Fayetteville, NY 13066